Ichabod Crane

Tom Mison

Lt. Abbie Mills

Nicole Beharie

Jenny Mills

Lyndie Greenwood

Captain Frank Irving

Orlando Jones

Katrina Crane

Katia Winter

Henry Parrish / —

John Noble

Guest Star

Max Brown

Guest Star

Johnathon Schaech

Sheriff Leena Reyes

Sakina Jaffrey

Guest Star

Steven Weber

Nick Hawley

Matt Barr

Guest Star

Adam Boyer

Benjamin Franklin

Timothy Busfield

Guest Star

Aunjanue Ellis

Guest Star

Michelle Trachtenberg

Guest Star

Colin Owens

Guest

Genevive Barker

Guest Star

Sharif Atkins

Guest Star

Heather Lind

Guest Star

Marc Menchaca

Guest Star

Jaime Murray

Guest Star

Francie Swift

Guest Star

Zach Appelman

Guest Star

Al-Jaleel Knox

Guest Star

Shelby Steel

Cynthia Irving

Jill Marie Jones

Guest Star

Patrick Gorman

Guest Star

Eddie Spears

Betsy Ross

Nikki Reed

Guest

Jesse C. Boyd

Guest Star

Adam Sinclair

Guest Star

Onira Tares

Guest Star

Ryan Gray

Guest Star

Caroline Ford

Guest Star

Chris Greene

Guest Star

Josh Carter*

Guest Star

Deborah Ayorinde

Headless Horseman

Jeremy Owens

Guest Star

Cynthia Stevenson

Andy Brooks

John Cho

Guest Star

Fernando Martínez

Moloch / Golem

Derek Mears

Guest

Lindsey Garrett

Daniel Reynolds

Lance Gross

Guest Star

Ashley LeConte Campbell

Guest Star

Laura Spencer

Guest Star

Tyler Chase

Guest Star

John Colton

Sheriff August Corbin

Clancy Brown

Guest Star

Surely Alvelo

Guest Star

Robin Strasds

Headless Horseman

Craig Branham

Pandora

Shannyn Sossamon

Guest Star

Tom Hillmann

Guest Star

Dane Rhodes

Abraham Van Brunt

Neil Jackson

Guest Star

Stephen Michael Ayers

Guest Star

Aaron Serotsky

Guest Star

Darla Delgado

Guest Star

Randy Havens

Guest

Belinda Keller

Guest Star

Annie Humphrey

Guest Star

Jeremy Palko

Guest Star

Myke Holmes

Guest Star

Allie McCulloch

Guest Star

Richard Fullerton

Guest Star

Ron Roggé

Guest Star

Michael Harding

Guest

Antwan Mills

Guest Star

Shane Callahan

Guest Star

Nick Jackson

Guest Star

Karen Boles

Guest Star

Daniel Thomas May

Scarecrow / Horseman of War / Wendigo

Marti Matulis

Guest Star

Katie Garfield

Guest Star

Shaun Clay

Guest Star

Austin Filson

Guest Star

Alan Wells

Guest Star

Joshua C. Allen

Guest Star

Elena Sanchez

Molly Thomas

Oona Yaffe

Guest Star

Morgan Hinkleman

Guest Star

Alan Heckner

Guest Star

Jessi Goei

Guest

Andrea Powell

Diana Thomas

Janina Gavankar

Guest Star

Barrett Carnahan

Guest Star

Greg Perrow

Guest Star

Parisa Johnston

Guest Star

Kimberley Drummond

Guest Star

Rob Maniscalco

Guest Star

Heather V. Regnier

Guest Star

Marc Farley

Guest Star

Alyssa Nicole Claytor

Guest Star

Suellen Yates

Alex Norwood

Rachel Melvin

Guest Star

Dane Davenport

Guest

Tia Robinson

Guest Star

Heather Gilliland

Guest Star

Jaret Sears

Guest Star

Victor Cordova

Guest Star

Connor McCabe

Guest Star

RJ Shearer

Guest Star

Eric Mainade

Guest Star

Luke Smith

Guest Star

Raven Angeline Whisnant

Guest

Jason Stuart

Guest Star

Jeff Sandor

Guest Star

Megan Hayes

Guest Star

Scott Parks

Guest Star

Katelyn Farrugia

Jake Wells

Jerry MacKinnon

Guest Star

Erika Edwards

Guest Star

Mary Russell

The Hidden One

Peter Mensah

Guest Star

Joy Jacobson

Guest Star

Devin McGee

Guest Star

Ed Wagenseller

Guest Star

Matt Mercurio

Guest Star

Braden Fitzgerald

Guest Star

Brett Kelley

Guest Star

Kevin Patrick Murphy

Guest Star

Michael Rosander

Guest Star

Scott Poythress

Guest Star

Jared Simon

Guest Star

Rochelle Aycoth

Detective Luke Morales / —

Nicholas Gonzalez

Moloch / Blurry Man

D.J. Mifflin

Randall Martin / Sam

Anthony K. Hyatt

Soldier

Chevy Lamont Cofield

Director

Douglas Aarniokoski

Director

Ken Olin

Director

Dwight H. Little