Shirley Jackson

Elisabeth Moss

Fred

Logan Lerman

Stanley Hyman

Michael Stuhlbarg

Rose Nemser / Paula

Odessa Young

Norman

Allen McCullough

Katherine

Victoria Pedretti

Henry

Steve Vinovich

Ralph Ellison

Edward O'Blenis

Ralph Ellison

Edward O'Blenis Jr.

Drunk Cad

Ryan Spahn

Randy Fisher

Robert Wuhl

Paula Double

Adelind Horan

Dean

Paul O'Brien

Caroline

Orlagh Cassidy

Faculty Wife

Molly Fahey

Peggy

Bisserat Tseggai

Taxi Driver

Mike Coleman

Drunken Fellow

Tony Manna

Party Guest

Thomas Racek

Rose's Friend

Ava Langford

Grad Student

Vincent McCauley

Prissy College Girl

Emily Decker

Partygoer

Lexa Hayes

Paula

Alexandria Sherman

Margarita Allen

Student

Susan Nido

Older Man

Warren Ray Davis

College Student

Melissa Chanza

Party Guest

Louise Schoene

Faculty Wife

Rosemary Howard

Director

Josephine Decker