Gwen

Kaytlin Borgen

Maya

Amber Benson

Dave

Taliesin Jaffe

Spencer

Morgan Peter Brown

Katrina

Whitney Moore

Frazer

Dove Meir

Nancy

Chloe Dykstra

Alicia

Jennifer Wenger

Samantha

Tiffany Smith

Matthew

Jeff Torres

Older Nancy

Julian Lambert

The Demon

Paradox Pollack

Anne

Daisy McCrackin

Derek

Brian Townes

Jeff

Jeff Berg

Dawn

Alexia Dox

Abby

Jen Araki

Natalie

Maryna Sokolovska

Gwen's Father

Michael Parness

Santa Claus

Fredy Ingels

Spencer's Father

Scott Tyler

Brian

Jordan Byrne

Bookstore Girl

Joelle Parness

Katrina's Mom

Helene Udy

Lifeguard

David Saenz

Woman at Pool

Bennett Cousins

Matthew's Wife

Bonnie Gordon

Man Outside Bar

Michael Hanna

Man Outside Bar

Henry Barajas