Sabrina Spellman

Melissa Joan Hart

Aunt Hilda Spellman

Caroline Rhea

Morgan Cavanaugh

Elisa Donovan

Roxie King

Soleil Moon Frye

Aunt Zelda Spellman

Beth Broderick

Harvey Kinkle

Nate Richert

Salem Saberhagen (voice)

Nick Bakay

Jennifer 'Jenny' Kelley

Michelle Beaudoin

Libby Chessler

Jenna Leigh Green

Mr. Eugene Pool

Paul Feig

Guest Star

Bridget Flannery

Guest Star

Karen Morrow

Guest Star

Robby Benson

Guest Star

Tom McGowan

Guest Star

Jack Wagner

Vesta

Raquel Welch

Guest Star

Violent Femmes

Tai Wai Tse

Cary Tagawa

Guest Star

Brady Anderson

Shelley

Kathy Ireland

Guest Star

Phil Fondacaro

Guest Star

Randy Travis

Guest Star

Sally Jessy Raphael

Guest Star

David Chokachi

Guest Star

Donna D'Errico

Guest Star

Dann Florek

Guest Star

Paul Michael Robinson

Guest Star

Coolio

Magic Joel

Andrew Keegan

Drell

Penn Jillette

Mrs. Bogzigian

Ella Joyce

Guest Star

Judith Jones

Guest Star

Dave Allen

Ethan

Paul Provenza

Guest Star

Peter Marshall

Guest Star

Carl Banks

Guest Star

Bryan Cranston

Guest Star

Wayne Duvall

Guest Star

Charlene Fernetz

Gustav

Robert Dorfman

Skippy

Teller

Marge

Sara Van Horn

Guest Star

Melissa Murray

Guest Star

Chris Elliott

Marigold

Robin Riker

Simon

Tom Wilson

Mr. James T. Rothwell

Ed Begley Jr.

Guest Star

Beverly Johnson

Judge Samuels

Henry Gibson

Guest Star

John Patrick White

Guest Star

Aeryk Egan

Guest Star

Alexandra Johnes

Guest Star

Aria Noelle Curzon

Amanda

Emily Hart

Guest Star

Cory Buck

Justin

Donald Adeosun Faison

Cassandra

Deborah Harry

Guest Star

Beth Kennedy

Guest Star

Sondra Spriggs

Guest Star

Patrick T. O'Brien

Guest Star

Susie Rossito

Monty

Dana Gould

Guest Star

John Loprieno

Trophy

Vien Hong

Newt

Billy West

Cicero

Mark Fite

Guest Star

Harold Sylvester

Guidance Counselor

Eddie Allen

Guest Star

Alan Young

Rules Bearer

Morwenna Banks

Emma

Elizabeth Hart

Guest Star

Frank Conniff

Randy the Destroyer

Marvin Jones II

Raphael

Darin Singleton

Guest Star

Berlinda Tolbert

Guest Star

Mika Boorem

Granny

Diane McBain

Guest Star

Jim Hanks

Clifford Weaver

Bumper Robinson

Guest Star

Bridget Flanery

Guest Star

Chuck McCann

Sasha

Nicole Bilderback

Guest Star

Kevin Nash

Gordie

Curtis Andersen

Teacher

Ariel Felix

Sherman

Henry Hien Cong

Zoe

Ally Holmes

Guest Star

Beth Howland

Guest Star

Sean Laughton

Lulu

Kery Norton

Guest Star

Diana Theodore

Guest Star

Brian Austin Green

Guest Star

Bubba Smith

Guest Star

Milo Ventimiglia

Guest Star

Steve Bannos

Guest Star

Angelo Vacco

Guest Star

Robin Krieger

Guest Star

Pancho Demmings

Guest Star

Curtis Anderson

Howard

James D. Fields

Guest Star

Jeff Witcher

Rex

Seth Adkins

Guest Star

Patty Toy

Mr. Altree

Jay Kogen

Matt Sabetti

John Knight

Joe

Joe O'Connor

Guest Star

Richard Grove

Guest Star

Evelyn Furtak

M'Lady

Linda Kash

Guest Star

Eddie Cibrian

Guest Star

James Fields

Guest Star

Phillip Glasser

Mrs. Hecht

Ren Woods

Mary

Karla DeVito

Male Student

Shaun Weiss

Guest Star

Bill Fagerbakke

Willard Kraft

Martin Mull

Valerie Birkhead

Lindsay Sloane

Quizmaster

Alimi Ballard