David 'Noodles' Aaronson

Robert De Niro

Maximilian 'Max' Bercovicz

James Woods

Deborah Gelly

Elizabeth McGovern

James Conway O'Donnell

Treat Williams

Carol

Tuesday Weld

Joe Minaldi

Burt Young

Frankie Minaldi

Joe Pesci

Police Chief Vincent Aiello

Danny Aiello

Patrick 'Patsy' Goldberg

James Hayden

Philip 'Cockeye' Stein

William Forsythe

'Fat' Moe Gelly

Larry Rapp

Eve

Darlanne Fluegel

Peggy

Amy Ryder

Van Linden

Dutch Miller

Young Noodles

Scott Schutzman Tiler

Young Max / David Bailey

Rusty Jacobs

Sharkey

Robert Harper

Chicken Joe

Richard Bright

Young Deborah

Jennifer Connelly

Young Patsy

Brian Bloom

Crowning

Gerard Murphy

Peggy

Amy S. Ryder

Young Cockeye

Adrian Curran

Woman in the Puppet Theater

Olga Karlatos

Young 'Fat' Moe Gelly

Mike Monetti

Dominic

Noah Moazezi

Mandy

Mario Brega

Trigger

Ray Dittrich

Bugsy

James Russo

Beefy

Frank Gio

Mrs. Aiello

Karen Shallo

Willie the Ape

Angelo Florio

Young Noodles

Scott Tiler

Young Peggy

Julie Cohen

Officer Whitey

Richard Foronjy

Young Fat Moe

Mike Monezzi

Al Capuano

Clem Caserta

Fred Capuano

Frank Sisto

Bugsy's Gang

Frankie Caserta

Johnny Capuano

Jerry Strivelli

Bugsy's Gang

Joey Marzella

Irving Gold

Mike Gendel

Friend of Young Deborah

Sandra Solberg

Young Deborah (Double)

Margherita Pace

Monkey

Paul Herman

Thug

Bruno Iannone

Interviewer

Marvin Scott

Max's Mother

Marcia Jean Kurtz

Girl in Coffin

Ann Neville

Adorable Old Man

Joey Faye

Nurse Thompson

Linda Ipanema

Reporter

Tandy Cronin

Reporter

Richard Zobel

Reporter

Baxter Harris

Chauffeur

Arnon Milchan

Cemetery Caretaker

Marty Licata

Peggy's Mother

Estelle Harris

Drunk

Gerritt Debeer

Ticket Agent

Sergio Leone

Newstand Man

Alexander Godfrey

Mounted Policeman

Cliff Cudney

2nd Mounted Policeman

Paul Farentino

Sgt. P. Halloran

Bruce Bahrenburg

Street Singer

Mort Freeman

Young Macrò

Massimo Liti

Foreman

Jay Zeely

Cis Corman

Scott Coffey