Melissa Gimble
Cecily Strong
Josh Skinner
Keegan-Michael Key
Reverend Layton
Fred Armisen
Florence Menlove / Madam Frau
Ann Harada
Mildred Layton
Kristin Chenoweth
Betsy McDonough / Jenny Banks
Dove Cameron
Mayor Menlove
Alan Cumming
Sergeant Rivera / Doc Jorge Lopez
Jaime Camil
Danny Bailey
Aaron Tveit
Emma Tate / Emcee
Ariana DeBose
The Countess
Jane Krakowski
Narrator
Tituss Burgess
Octavius Kratt
Patrick Page
Carson
Liam Quiring-Nkindi
Pete the Milkman
Amitai Marmorstein
Core Dancer
Amanda Cleghorn
Core Dancer
Serena Crouse
Core Dancer
Sarah Formosa
Core Dancer
Julia Harnett
Core Dancer
Shelley Stewart Hunt
Core Dancer
Ericka Hunter
Core Dancer
Jessica Keeling
Core Dancer
Marina Lazzaretto
Core Dancer
Caitriona Murphy
Core Dancer
Katrina Reynolds
Core Dancer
Ashley Brooke St. John
Farmer McDonough
Kevin McNulty
Tootie McDonough
Bijou Brattston
Innkeeper Harvey
Darcey Johnson
Larry the Fireman
Scott Patey
Henry the Iceman
Garfield Wilson
Core Dancer
Jak Barradell
Core Dancer
Daniel Bernardo
Core Dancer
Julio Fuentes
Core Dancer
Tristan Chad Ghostkeeper
Core Dancer
Jared Khalifa
Core Dancer
Troy Mclaughlin
Core Dancer
Gray Monczka
Core Dancer
Matt Nethersole
Core Dancer
Derek Piquette
Core Dancer
Sam Strasfeld
Core Dancer
Warren Yang
Carrie
Kyra Leroux
Nellie
Astrid Trueman
Old Doc Lopez
Pedro Salvín
Helen
Sarah Hayward
Mrs. Lopez
Michelle Rios
Freckle-Faced Girl
Viola Abley
Buck-Toothed Boy
Nolen Dubuc
Wild Hair Boy
Ridley Havok McLeod
Tap Dancer / Choir
Peyton Amelia Feltham
Tap Dancer / Choir
Anthony Juo
Tap Dancer / Choir
Ema Lake
Tap Dancer / Choir
Jenna Lamb
Tap Dancer / Choir
Alisa Lymar
Tap Dancer / Choir
Leah Park
Choir / Tap Dancer
Matias Wong
Freddy
Alex Barima
Nancy
Cassandra Consiglio
Madam Vina
Peppermint
Marv
Timothy Webber
Corn Puddin' Cook
David Adams
Buford Riggs
Jason Burkart
Waitress
Stephanie Cho
Husband Ted
Thomas Wayne Hum
Like Minded Guy
Levi McCachen
Joanna
Iris Quinn
Undertaker
Nikolai Witschl
Birthing Woman Holly
Leana Yu
Leprechaun
Martin Short
DJ
Style Dayne
Bridesmaid
Whitney Lykins
Bride
Rryla McIntosh
Young Woman #1
Alex Gullason
Young Woman #2
Emma Pedersen
Woman #3
Arielle Tuliao
Tap Dancer
Inca Scott
Biddy #1
Dolores Drake
Biddy #2
Eileen Barrett