Various Characters
Keegan-Michael Key
Various Characters
Jordan Peele
Tracey
Christina Anthony
Ty Burrell
Pegasus Fan
Jordan Black
Lance Barber
Christian S. Anderson
Larry Joe Campbell
Erin Gibson
Colton Dunn
White Guy in Negraph Commercial
Rob Delaney
Mars Crain
Himself
Ron Artest
Edward Fordham Jr.
Nyima Funk
Josh Fadem
Person at People Park #3 / Overweight Guy
Paul Walter Hauser
Anna Maria Horsford
Madison Mason
Pegasus Protester
Daniele Gaither
Georgiana
Reatha Grey
Guy Stevenson
Barista
Sarah Baker
Joshua Funk
Drew Droege
Pegasus Witness
Ace Gibson
Laron's Friend #2
Yassir Lester
Rap Battle Host
Lloyd Ahlquist
Fantine
Nicole Parker
Benjamin Button Man
Leslie David Baker
Himself
Jason Schwartzman
Zachary's Mom
Erika L. Holmes
Mary Magdalene
Michaela Watkins
Civil War General
Mark Moses
Dance Judge
Maribeth Monroe
Sarah Schwartzman
Chelsea Cook
Denise (as Leslie Miller)
Leslie L. Miller
Character
Cynthia Blaise
Character
Cale Hartmann
Character
Lily Holleman
Marc Evan Jackson
Character
Casey Washington
Little Prisoner
Dana Michael Woods
Prisoner
Kelle Whitehurst
Minister
Harry Zinn