Jamie Waring

Tyrone Power

Margaret Denby

Maureen O'Hara

Capitán Morgan

Laird Cregar*

Capt. Sir Henry Morgan

Laird Cregar

Tom "Tommie" Blue

Thomas Mitchell

Capt. Billy Leech

George Sanders

Wogan

Anthony Quinn

Lord Denby

George Zucco

Roger Ingram

Edward Ashley

Don Miguel

Fortunio Bonanova

Lady in Waiting in the Courtroom (uncredited)

Bonnie Bannon

Don Miguel

Fortunio Bonanova

Capt. Graham

Stuart Robertson

Fenner

Charles McNaughton

Captain Blaine (uncredited)

John Burton

Mr. Fenner

Charles McNaughton

Dancer (uncredited)

Rita Christiani

Speaker of Assembly

Frederick Worlock

Woman (uncredited)

Helene Costello

Chinese Cook

Willie Fung

Woman (uncredited)

Bryn Davis

Capt. Higgs

Charles Francis

Town Crier (uncredited)

William Edmunds

The Bishop

Arthur Shields

Majordomo

Keith Hitchcock

Flossy Woman with Tommy (uncredited)

Jody Gilbert

Capt. Jones

Cyril McLaglen

Assemblyman (uncredited)

Arthur Gould-Porter

Sailor (uncredited)

Rondo Hatton

Margaret's Servant

Clarence Muse

Clerk Reading Proclamation

Olaf Hytten

Sea Captain

Charles Irwin

Sea Captain

David Thursby

Assemblyman (uncredited)

Boyd Irwin

Sea Captain

Frank Leigh

Pirate (uncredited)

Jack Kenny

Assemblyman (uncredited)

George Kirby

Pirate (uncredited)

Jack Low

Pirate (uncredited)

Frank McGrath

Pirate (uncredited)

Constantine Romanoff

Assemblyman (uncredited)

C. Montague Shaw

Director

Henry King

Director

Henry King