Aurora Teagarden

Candace Cameron Bure

Nick Miller

Niall Matter

Aida Teagarden

Marilu Henner

Sally Allison

Lexa Doig

Arthur Smith

Peter Benson

James Reading

Oliver Rice

Lynn Smith

Miranda Frigon

Miya Quan

Elfina Luk

Phillip Pifer

Dylan Sloane

Howard Kane

Chris Gauthier

Lillian Tibbett

Ellie Harvie

Davis Mettle

Cole Vigue

Terry Sternholz

Catherine Lough Haggquist

Eric Hanson

Brendon Zub

Kelly Stevens

Michelle Harrison

Brett Talbot

Sean Depner

David Reyes

Jay Hindle

Callie Reyes

Lisa Marie DiGiacinto

Leo Stevens

Byron Mayberry

Jewelry Shop Owner

Forbes Angus

Lawyer Julia

Ellen Ewusie

Security Guard

Shaw Madson

Shop Customer

David Godfrey

Miya's Lawyer

Leah Thom