Buck Weaver
John Cusack
Oscar 'Hap' Felsch
Charlie Sheen
Charles 'Commie' Comiskey
Clifton James
'Shoeless' Joe Jackson
D.B. Sweeney
Arnold Rothstein
Michael Lerner
Bill Burns
Christopher Lloyd
Kid Gleason
John Mahoney
Dickie Kerr
Jace Alexander
Ray Schalk
Gordon Clapp
Eddie Cicotte
David Strathairn
Eddie Collins
Bill Irwin
Charles "Swede" Risberg
Don Harvey
'Shoeless' Joe Jackson
D. B. Sweeney
Fred McMullin
Perry Lang
Chick Gandil
Michael Rooker
Claude 'Lefty' Williams
James Read
Ring Lardner
John Sayles
Hugh Fullerton
Studs Terkel
Billy Maharg
Richard Edson
Smitty (as Jim Desmond)
James Desmond
Abe Attell
Michael Mantell
Joseph 'Sport' Sullivan
Kevin Tighe
Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis
John Anderson
Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis
John Anderson
Ban Johnson
Clyde Bassett
Kate Jackson
Wendy Makkena
Rose Cicotte
Maggie Renzi
John Heydler
Eliot Asinof
Helen Weaver
Barbara Garrick
Rothstein's Lawyer
John Craig
Lyria Williams
Nancy Travis
Alfred Austrian
Michael Laskin
Ben Short
Bill Raymond
Monk
Stephen Mendillo
Michael Ahearn
Randle Mell
District Attorney
Robert Motz
Rothstein's lawyer
John D. Craig
PeeWee
Brad Garrett
Bucky
Tay Strathairn
Singer
Lee Anne Harris
Scooter
Jesse Vincent
Fan
Jack George
Fan
Tom Surber
Heckler
Ken Berry
Enemy Fan
David Rice
Fan
Tom Ledcke
Browns Umpire
Tom Marshall
Fan
David Carpenter
Fan
Bert Hatch
Grabiner
Merrill Holtzman
Writer
Jerry Brent
Winslow
Josh Thompson
Writer
Bruce Schumacher
Singer
Leigh Harris
Jimmy
Philip Murphy
Writer
Robert Walsh
Writer
Matthew Harrington
Reds Player
J. Dennis Newman
Writer
Richard Lynch
Reds Catcher
Charles Siebert II
Writer
Gary Williams
Cincinnati Umpire
Jim Martindale
New Jersey Fans
Michael Preston
Writer (as Michael Harris)
Michael L. Harris
Chicago Umpire
Bill Jennings
Announcer
David Hinman
Enemy Fan
B.J. Davis
Hired Killer
Danton Stone
Irish Tenor
Patrick Grant
Betting Man
Tim Laughter
Attendant
Brad Armacost
Judge Friend
Dick Cusack
Clerk
Eaton Randles
Nash
Max Chiddester
Jury Foreman
Rich Komenich
Smitty
Jim Desmond
Writer
Richard Lynch
Writer
Garry Williams
Writer
Michael Harris
Woman in Bar
Julie Whitney
Woman in Bar
Dana Roi
Reporter
Jim Stark
Reporter
Brad Griffith
Reporter
Steve Salge
New Jersey Fan
Patrick Brown
New Jersey Fan
John Greisemer
New Jersey Fan
Charles Yankoglu
New Jersey Fan
Mike Preston