Buck Weaver

John Cusack

Oscar 'Hap' Felsch

Charlie Sheen

Charles 'Commie' Comiskey

Clifton James

'Shoeless' Joe Jackson

D.B. Sweeney

Arnold Rothstein

Michael Lerner

Bill Burns

Christopher Lloyd

Kid Gleason

John Mahoney

Dickie Kerr

Jace Alexander

Ray Schalk

Gordon Clapp

Eddie Cicotte

David Strathairn

Eddie Collins

Bill Irwin

Charles "Swede" Risberg

Don Harvey

'Shoeless' Joe Jackson

D. B. Sweeney

Fred McMullin

Perry Lang

Arnold 'Chick' Gandil

Michael Rooker

Claude 'Lefty' Williams

James Read

Ring Lardner

John Sayles

Hugh Fullerton

Studs Terkel

Billy Maharg

Richard Edson

Smitty (as Jim Desmond)

James Desmond

Abe Attell

Michael Mantell

Joseph 'Sport' Sullivan

Kevin Tighe

Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis

John Anderson

Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis

John Anderson

Ban Johnson

Clyde Bassett

Kate Jackson

Wendy Makkena

Rose Cicotte

Maggie Renzi

John Heydler

Eliot Asinof

Helen Weaver

Barbara Garrick

Rothstein's Lawyer

John Craig

Lyria Williams

Nancy Travis

Alfred Austrian

Michael Laskin

Ben Short

Bill Raymond

Monk

Stephen Mendillo

Michael Ahearn

Randle Mell

District Attorney

Robert Motz

Rothstein's lawyer

John D. Craig

PeeWee

Brad Garrett

Bucky

Tay Strathairn

Singer

Lee Anne Harris

Scooter

Jesse Vincent

Fan

Jack George

Fan

Tom Surber

Heckler

Ken Berry

Enemy Fan

David Rice

Fan

Tom Ledcke

Browns Umpire

Tom Marshall

Fan

David Carpenter

Fan

Bert Hatch

Grabiner

Merrill Holtzman

Writer

Jerry Brent

Winslow

Josh Thompson

Writer

Bruce Schumacher

Singer

Leigh Harris

Jimmy

Philip Murphy

Writer

Robert Walsh

Writer

Matthew Harrington

Writer

Richard Lynch

Reds Player

J. Dennis Newman

Reds Catcher

Charles Siebert II

Writer

Gary Williams

Cincinnati Umpire

Jim Martindale

New Jersey Fans

Michael Preston

Writer (as Michael Harris)

Michael L. Harris

Chicago Umpire

Bill Jennings

Announcer

David Hinman

Enemy Fan

B.J. Davis

Hired Killer

Danton Stone

Irish Tenor

Patrick Grant

Betting Man

Tim Laughter

Attendant

Brad Armacost

Judge Friend

Dick Cusack

Clerk

Eaton Randles

Nash

Max Chiddester

Jury Foreman

Rich Komenich

Smitty

Jim Desmond

Writer

Garry Williams

Writer

Michael Harris

Woman in Bar

Julie Whitney

Woman in Bar

Dana Roi

Reporter

Jim Stark

Reporter

Brad Griffith

Reporter

Steve Salge

New Jersey Fan

Patrick Brown

New Jersey Fan

John Greisemer

New Jersey Fan

Charles Yankoglu

New Jersey Fan

Mike Preston

Director

John Sayles