Susan Smith

Emilia Clarke

Jolene

Thora Birch

Mark Putnam

Jack Huston

Cash

Johnny Knoxville

Kathy Putnam

Sophie Lowe

Randy McCoy

Austin Hébert

Bob Singer

Kevin Dunn

Joe-Bea

Karl Glusman

Todd Eason

Chris Mulkey

Georgia Beale

Brittany O'Grady

Denver Rhodes

Omar Benson Miller

Rufus

Brian Lee Franklin

Ricky

Joshua Mikel

Bones

Luke Spencer Roberts

Susan's Daughter

Lex Kelli

Susan's Son

Landon Durrence

Agent Baumgarten

Lance E. Nichols

Joe B.'s Mother(as Nettie Mae Kraft)

Nettie Kraft

Murph(as Robert Treveiler)

Robert C. Treveiler

Bumpy

Taxo Michaels

Matt Boylan

Frank Hoyt Taylor

Bank Teller

Katie Campbell

Stan Jones

Daniel R. Hill

Beth

Phoebe Plasto

Anita Farmer Bergman

FBI Lawyer

Jim Klock

Vergena Fields

Jolene's Customer

Colleen Camp

Court Clerk

Louie Lawless

Courtroom Spectator

Kathlene Ashcraft

Counter Woman

Valerie Payton

Mark and Cathy's Daughter

Claire Lawrence

Bank Officer

Brian Leedy

Courtroom Spectator

Patrick Alred

Stenographer

Lea Hutton Beasmore