Lindsey

Marla Sokoloff

Cassie

Marie Osmond

Wes Bailey

Rob Mayes

Aunt Maggie

Jan Broberg

Mark

Jacob Young

Allie

Whitney Palmer

Marilyn

Anna Daines

Innkeeper

Jill Adler

Gwen

Melanie Haynes

Monica

Eliza de Azevedo Brown

Bartender/Cowboy

John Forker

Wes' Mom

Taunya Gren

Street performer / Concert attendee

Nikolas Mikkelsen

Lady #1

Cat Hammons

Friend

Nicole Dukes

Erica

Clotile Yanna

Christmas Pageant Attendee

Jerome Brad Halgren

Robby

Brian Robinson

Lady #2

Jonez Cain

Tyler

Kenneth Cummins

Sister Catherine

Laurie Harrop-Purser

Kid Narrator

Charlie Stover

Kid Angel

Sage Pederson

Waitress

Carlie Young

Ticket Salesperson

David Stanley