Tess Harper
Lacey Chabert
Lt. Logan O'Connor
Brennan Elliott
Chief O'Connor
John Kapelos
Aunt Candace
Barbara Niven
Winston Sams
Romaine Waite
Josephine
Genevieve Kang
Alistair
Noam Jenkins
Reed
Steve Belford
Bianca
Kaitlyn Leeb
Rocco
Paulino Nunes
Cormac
Matthew Gouveia
Julia Marquez
Cynthia Preston
Delivery Man
Boomer Phillips
Will
Will Shortz
Dr. Cohen
Nigel Downer
Paul Drexler
Chris Handfield
Coroner's Clerk
Milton Barnes
Maude
Trudy Weiss
Sinclair
Jayne Lewis
Tamara
Jill Frappier
Antiques Dealer
Darryl Hinds
Landlord
Jim Calarco
Chess Player #1
Aaron Richards
Magic Show Patron
Chris Tarpos