Allison Bennet

Rachel Boston

Martha

Patricia Richardson

Matthew

Andrew Walker

Mrs. Claus

Caroline Rhea

Olivia Brentley

Kate Moyer

Jeff Mulligan

Paul Essiembre

Mayor Paul

Bill Lake

Rose (as Marina Stephenson)

Marina Stephenson Kerr

Rebecca Rowe

Stephanie Moroz

Bill

Harry Nelken

Sarah Grace

Susanna Portnoy

Lindsey

Cherissa Richards

Yates

Mrs. Bucklin

Thanya Romero

Josie Andelman

Stephanie Sy

Clive

Blake Taylor

Pedestrian (uncredited)

Derek James Trapp

Monsieur Claus

Tom Young

Church Member

Jim Kirby

Matthew's Brother

Kevin Klassen

Matthew's Mother

Megan MacArton