Peter

Charlie Day

Emma Moore

Jenny Slate

Noah

Scott Eastwood

Anne

Gina Rodriguez

Logan

Manny Jacinto

Ginny

Clark Backo

Trevor

Luke David Blumm

Chloe

Giselle Torres

Leighton

Isabel May

Paul

Mason Gooding

Lisa

Dylan Gelula

Taylor

Quinn Cooke

Sylvia

Claudia Rocafort

Jase

Pete Davidson

Toby

Kysen Acevedo

Janine

Lauren Halperin

Rita

Jami Gertz

Middle School Girlfriend

Betsy Sligh

Middle School Boyfriend

Braxton Alexander

Matt

Thy Bui

Mark

Jordan Carlos

Audrey

Saya Watkins

Dentist

Marco Schittone

Audience Member

Franco Castan

Waitress

Jessi Goei

Midori Francis

Seymour

Manny Magnus

Old Woman

Polly Craig

Receptionist

Lynne Ashe

Stage Manager

Yannis Kitas

Atlanta Bro #2

Julian Williams

Leighton's Dad

Ben McKenzie

Atlanta Bro #3

Austin Seifert

Plant

Spencer Murrill

Pastor

Kenneth Rouché

Playground Kid (uncredited)

Ava Ann Gale

Birthday Party Kid

Chloe Camp

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Linda D Gaines