Joseph Morelli

Jason O'Mara

Stephanie Plum

Katherine Heigl

Ranger

Daniel Sunjata

Lula

Sherri Shepherd

Jimmy Alpha

John Leguizamo

Grandma Mazur

Debbie Reynolds

Mrs. Plum

Debra Monk

Eddie Gazarra

Nate Mooney

Vinnie Plum

Patrick Fischler

Bernie Kuntz

Adam Paul

Connie

Ana Reeder

Jackie

Ryan Michelle Bathe

William Earling

Harry O'Toole

Morty Beyers

Fisher Stevens

John Cho

Leonardo Nam

Mary Lou

Annie Parisse

Lenny

Daniel Mastrogiorgio

Benito Ramirez

Gavin-Keith Umeh

Mr. Plum

Louis Mustillo

Rex

Rex the Hamster

Mooch Morelli

John Joseph Williams

Police Woman

Lisa Ann Goldsmith

Waitress

Jennifer Vos

Tiffany Sander McKenzie

Carmen's Neighbor

David Early

Sunny

Marla Sucharetza

Criminal (uncredited)

Jackson Nunn

Mama Morelli

Angela Pietropinto

Carmen

Alexis Treadwell-Murray

Cop #1

Jake Andolina

Cop #2

Joshua Elijah Reese

David L. Early

Shaw Street Thug

Robert Oppel

Old Man on Street

Bo Graham

Grandson

Carnel McMorris Jr.

Rosa Gomez

Olga Merediz

Darren

Jared Pfennigwerth

Jersey Girl #1

Alexis Ferrante

Jersey Girl #2

Alana Hixson

Noisy Neighbor

Kathleen Murray

Ross Meyerson