Josephine Prendergast
Ellen Burstyn
Jared Whitcomb
Alex Wolff
Sebastian Prendergast
Asa Butterfield
Alan Whitcomb
Nick Offerman
Meredith Whitcomb
Maude Apatow
Mrs. Whitcomb
Michaela Watkins
Tour Video Narrator (voice)
Fred Armisen
St. Peder's Church Youth Group
Debbie Aderinkomi
Alec
Alec George
St. Peder's Church Youth Group
Emmylou Barden
University Receptionist
Shelley Dowdy
St. Peder's Church Youth Group
David Krug
University Administrator
Senay Matewos
St. Peder's Church Youth Group
Edduar Peralta Carmen
Rash Fan
Paul Cram
Male Cop
Ansa Akyea
Female Cop
Dawn Orgon
College Student
Karla Alvarez
College Student
Josh Cisewski
The Rabbit Holes
Taylor Harris
Punk Rocker
Dustin Gill
The Rabbit Holes
Adam Bubolz
Church Patron
Brian Grossman
Punk Rocker
Logan Hamman
Punk Rocker
Jake Hinkley
Townie Party Goer
Jennifer Kelzenberg-Shea
Punk Rock Dude (Makeout Couple) (uncredited)
Joseph Bezenek
Shoeless Jeff (uncredited)
Ryan J. Gilmer
Biker Party Guest
Gwen Ruhoff
(uncredited)
Dallas Hilde Smith
(uncredited)
Andrew Stecker
Buckminster Fuller
College Professor
Valerie Rose
Party Boy
Aaron Schwab