Brad Sexton

Tim Allen

Caroline Sexton

Kirstie Alley

Samuel Yoder

Jay O. Sanders

Bob Lachman

Wayne Knight

Inspector Derek Lester

Larry Miller

Phil Kleinman

Michael Lerner

Steuerfahnder Frank Hall

Miguel A. Núñez Jr.

Levinia Yoder

Megan Cavanagh

Henner Lapp

John Pyper-Ferguson

Rebecca Yoder

Carrie Preston

Jerry - Good Guys Realty

Ethan Phillips

Anna Yoder

Katie Moore

Dave - Good Guys Realty

John Caponera

Judge Joan Northcott

June Claman

Samuel Yoder Jr.

Bobby Steggert

Cynthia

Marla Maples

Sammy Yoder

Michael Angarano

Grandma Yoder

Rosemary Knower

Grandpa Yoder

David Harscheid

Baby Yoder

Hunter Stover

Baby Yoder

Scout Stover

Mary

Holly Cross Vagley

Mary

Holly Rudkin

Penny, Brad's secretary

Crystal Bock

Hannah Yoder

Monica Deeter

Jonathan Yoder

Richard Pelzman

Sarah

Madeline Mager

Elder Joseph

Terrence Currier

Elder Thomas

Hal Handerson

Bailiff

Michael Howell

Emma Yoder

Johanna Cox

Elder Thomas

Hal Henderson

Jacob Yoder

Stefan Aleksander

Bank Teller

Holly Atkinson

Malik the Cabbie

Anthony Azizi

Evelyn, Phil's secretary

Emily Chamberlain

IRS Agent

David Maples

George

Markus Flanagan

Tourist Man

Wes Johnson

Tom

Rick Foucheux

Waitress

Drenda Spohnholtz

Stacy

Marla Sucharetza

Young Amish Man (uncredited)

Kirk Alexander

Amish Dancer (uncredited)

Kurt Gerard

Runway Model (uncredited)

Natasha Gill

Amish Woman (uncredited)

Mandy Kriss

Champagne Waiter (uncredited)

John Michaelson

Prisoner (uncredited)

Bryan Spicer

Police Officer (uncredited)

Mark Norris

Stockbroker (uncredited)

Nick Stellate

New York Socialite (uncredited)

LauraLee O'Shell

Amish Elder (uncredited)

David Scott Taylor

New Yorker (uncredited)

Tom Templeton