Jenny

Katherine Heigl

Kitty

Alexis Bledel

Eddie

Tom Wilkinson

Rose

Linda Emond

Anne

Grace Gummer

Denny

Sam McMurray

Michael

Matthew Metzger

Ellen

Diana Hardcastle

Lorraine

Cathleen O'Malley

Frankie

Houston Rhines

Aaron

Alex Wake

Fireman #1

Ed Ackerman

Fireman #2

William Watterson

Fireman #2

Bill Watterson

Fireman #3

Joshua Elijah Reese

Barbara Ellen

Betsie Devan

Marion

Hollis McCarthy

Saleswoman

Ann Hagemann

Aaron

Alex T. Wake

Priest

Greg Violand

Tommy

Seamus Tierney

Godfather #2

Tom Kondilas

Female Godparent

Sarah Ann Kinsey

Male Godparent #1

Matthew O'Shea

Businessman (uncredited)

Amechi Okocha

Margaret

Kenya Gest

DJ at Wedding

Jerome "Tony" Harris Jr.

Minister

John Donoghue