Elizabeth Carter

Haylie Duff

Mitch Becker

Chris Soldevilla

Donna

Leslie Easterbrook

Laura

Angie Everhart

Sally

Joyce Hyser

Jake Jones

Scott Michael Campbell

Staci

Alexandra Manea

Dave Breem

Kelly Perine

Date #3

Alison Becker

Rudy

Eric Scott Woods

Stan Jones

Conrad Bachmann

Pilot

Eddie Jemison

Carl

Ryan Sanson

Tess

Sophie Tilson

Shelby

Sandra Taylor

Eddie

Terryl Daluz

Tommy

Greg Lindsay

Veterinarian

Bob Bancroft

Linda

Eleanor Wells

Lucky

Joe Russell

Referee

James Doherty

Becky

Lisa Renée

Day Official

Jordann Kimley

Night Official

Enrico Natale

Aloha Employee

Jeff Jonas

Karen

Brandy Redd

Waitress

Erin Storm

Priest

Isaac Stephen Montgomery

Talk show host

Kristin Herold

Whip Winner

Joe Webber

Wedding Guest

Shannon Bobo

Usher #1

Eric Anthony

Police Officer

John Farley

Marathon girl (uncredited)

Lauren Greg