Brooke

Vanessa Hudgens

Madison

Emmanuelle Chriqui

Sir Cole

Josh Whitehouse

Sir Geoffrey

Harry Jarvis

Old Crone / Mrs. Claus

Ella Kenion

Alyson

Mimi Gianopulos

Claire

Isabelle Franca

Patrick (uncredited)

Jacob Soley

Christmas Caroler #2

Andrea Senior

David

Jean-Michel Le Gal

Officer Stevens

Arnold Pinnock

Group Singer

Telysa Chandler

Evan

Scott Ryan Yamamura

Kaelynn - James' Girlfriend

Olivia Gudaniec

Eileen

Jayne Eastwood

Paige

Shanice Johnson

Older Brother

Jonah Wineberg

Santa Claus

Scott Edgecombe

Teenage Girl

Hayley Festeryga

Mrs Claus

Kristin Shepherd

James - Brooke's Ex

Neil Babcock

Taylor

Jesse Gervasi

An elf / Paige's friend

Piper Stauffer

Young Wife at Tree Farm

Brittany Rae Robinson

Young Husband at Tree Farm

Alex Armbruster

Reed

Simon Webster

Will

Evan O'Donnell

Lily

Shazdeh Kapadia

Abby Sutton

Kat Graham

Derek

Rob Lowe

Caroler

Chantal Saab

Kate (archive footage)

Kristin Davis

Josh Barton

Quincy Brown

Knight

Chris Hobbs