Ethan Miller

Joshua Leonard

Corinne Walker

Vera Farmiga

Pastor Bill

Norbert Leo Butz

Kathleen Walker

Donna Murphy

Young Corinne Walker

McKenzie Turner

CW

John Hawkes

Annika

Dagmara Dominczyk

Salesman

Matthew Dubas

Young Wendy Walker

Taylor Schwencke

Mrs. Tuttle

Jillian Lindig

Wendy Walker

Nina Arianda

Tim

Alden Rosakranse

Teenage Corinne Walker

Taissa Farmiga

Pastor Bud

Bill Irwin

Mark

Ebon Moss-Bachrach

Kirk

James Noon

Teenage Ethan Miller

Boyd Holbrook

Teenage Wendy Walker

Kaitlyn Rae King

Mike

Brandon Boyer

Ned

Michael Chernus

Renegade

Harrison Basch

Renegade

Noah Bowman

Biology Teacher

Booker James Winter

Liam Donovan

Sean Mahon

Dr. Dick Adams

Jack Gilpin

Younger Abigail Miller

Luella Roche

Molly

Molly Hawkey

Younger Lily Miller

Sarah Banks

Gabe's Teacher (uncredited)

Dannielle Rose

Deborah

Barbara Tuttle

Dr. Frank Barnes

Frank Goodyear

Hope

Reagan Leonard

Woody

Charles Glaser

Joanna

Lucy Owen

Cop

Joseph Sinagra

Older Abigail Miller

Sarah Little

Older Lily Miller

Zoe Pipa

Gabe Miller

Mathew Biltonen

Nurse

Sonia T. Gittens

7-Year-Old Boy

Eli Rubinstein

Amy

Amy Helm

Machan

Machan Taylor

Jorgen

Jorgen Jorgenson

Man in Counseling Office

Tom Cherwin

Woman in Counseling Office

Laurel S. Andretta

Receptionist

Karen Keefe

Liam's Wife

Natalie Thomas

Pawn Shop Worker

Terry McKenna

Faye

Deborah Hedwall

Warren

Warren Haynes

Oliver

Oliver Wood