Laurel/Audrey

Zoe Kazan

Basel

Jake Johnson

Frank

John Carroll Lynch

Charles

Ron Livingston

Dr. Rao

Danny Pudi

Hunter

Sterling Beaumon

May

Shae D'Lyn

Claudia

Frankie Shaw

Laurel/Audrey Double

Katherine Macanufo

James

Jeremy Howard

Edith

Sabrina Lloyd

Hunter's Mom

Robin Reiser

Patrick

Luka Jones

Perfect Mom

Bronwyn Cornelius

Mrs. Shoemacher

Dale Raoul

Perfect Dad

Patrick Breen

Perfect Boy

Stuart Littlefield

Mrs. Matthews

Meagan Fay

Darren Matthews

Joel Cooper

Perfect Girl

Rosa Yelena Schorr

David Matthews

Michael Alferoff

Ralph

Mark Kelly

Droopy Priest

Bob Larkin

Tall Husband

Rick Lechowick

Marguerite

Jennifer Lafleur

Funeral Boy #1

Devan Leos

Short Wife

Anne Gregory

Funeral Boy #2

William Kronfeld

Rockabilly Hairdresser

Audi Resendez

Timor

Akinsola Aribo

Peter

Luke Colombero

Halloween Kid

Tyler Nunes

Halloween Kid

Joey Fernandes

Halloween Kid

Vincent Castro

Squat Old Lady

Annie O'Donnell

Halloween Kid

Luke Trujillo

Old Lady

Judith Durning

Halloween Kid

Isiah Greene

Old Lady

Judith Drake

Halloween Kid

Zeve Zilberberg

Annette

Lylah Dixon

Tiny Old Man

Vthongdee Sookdet

Hunter's Sister

Kaila Kastan

Dishwasher

David Christison

Doctor

Richard Fortune

Nurse #1

Joanne Scott

Nurse #2

Stephanie Guerrero

Physical Therapist

Carol Gardner

Flight Attendant

Fatima Dzagoeva

Little Girl

Frankie Wass

Little Girl's Mom

Jenée LaMarque

Halloween Kid

Katana Boyer

Halloween Kid

Samara Owens

Halloween Mom

Leoni Mendoza

Halloween Mom

Abby Leboff

Halloween Mom

Patricia Diaz

Young Hot Guy

Julian Wass