Police Commissioner Rhinelander Waldo

James Cagney

Younger Brother

Brad Dourif

Coalhouse Walker Jr.

Howard Rollins

Evelyn Nesbit Thaw

Elizabeth McGovern

Mother

Mary Steenburgen

Booker T. Washington

Moses Gunn

Willie Conklin

Kenneth McMillan

Mr. Delphin Delmas

Pat O'Brien

Evelyn's Dance Instructor

Donald O'Connor

Father

James Olson

Tateh

Mandy Patinkin

Sarah

Debbie Allen

Harry Houdini

Jeff Demunn

Henry "Harry" Kendall Thaw

Robert Joy

Stanford White

Norman Mailer

Jerome

Bruce Boa

Brigit

Hoolihan Burke

P.C. O'Donnell

Jeff Daniels

Brigit

Hoolihand Burke

Mameh

Fran Drescher

Gent No. 1 - Agent

Norman Chancer

Grandfather

Edwin Cooper

Gang Member 1

Frankie Faison

Police Captain No. 1

Hal Galili

Judge

Alan Gifford

Delmas' Assistant No. 1

Richard Griffiths

Gang Member No. 2

Samuel L. Jackson

Special Reporter

Michael Jeter

Gang Member No. 3

Calvin Levels

Old Lady - T.O.C.

Bessie Love

Police Captain No. 2

Christopher Malcolm

Vernon Elliott

Herman Meckler

Delmas' Assistant No. 2

Billy J. Mitchell

Little Girl

Jenny Nichols

Little Boy

Max Nichols

Gent No. 2 - Manager

Zack Norman

Inspector McNeil

Don Plumley

Mrs. Thaw

Eloise Taylor

Black Lawyer

Ted Ross

Gang Member No. 4

Dorsey Wright

Foreman of the Jury

Robert Arden

President Theodore Roosevelt

Robert Boyd

Vice President Charles Warren Fairbanks

Thomas A. Carlin

Plainclothes Detective No. 1

John Clarkson

Fireman No. 1

E. Brian Dean

County Clerk

Harry Ditson

Fireman No. 1

Brian F. Dean

Gent with Stanford White

Robert Dorning

Police Guard - T.O.C.

Geoffrey Greenhill

Policeman No. 12

Ray Hassett

Plainclothes Detective No. 2

Robert Hitt

Sleek Male Dancer

Rodney James

Band Leader, Clef Club

George Harris

Novely Shop Storeman

George J. Manos

Clef Club Manager

Val Pringle

Doctor Muller

Ron Weyand

Gent No. 3 - Lawyer

Bill Reimbold

Woman with Stanford White

Norris Mailer

Police Sergeant

Douglas Lambert

Policeman

Nesbitt Blaisdell

Policeman

Joel Cutrara

Policeman

Jeff Harding

Policeman

Andreas Katsulas

Policeman

Joe Praml

Policeman

Bob Sherman

Fireman

Josh Clark

Fireman

Jake Dengel

Fireman

John Ratzenberger

J.P. Morgan

Donald Bisset

Waldo's Aide

John Alderson

Waldo's Aide

Patrick Connor

Waldo's Aide

Derek Martin

Desk Clerk

Robert Coffin

Black Butler

Britt Walker

Thug

Pat Gorman

Thug

Stan Simmons

Stage Manager

Barry Dennen

Stock Reporter

Tony Sibbald

Stock Reporter

Richard Oldfield

Elderly Woman

Gretchen Franklin

Elderly Man

Robert Henderson

Solomon Peretz

Pavel Landovsky

maitre d'

Al Matthews

Lawyer's Female Companion

Colette Hiller

Ina, Lawyer's Female Companion

Elaine Ives-Cameron

Guard at Family House

Ethan Phillips

Library guard

John Sterland

Special reporter

Jan Triska

Reporter

Burnell Tucker

Conductor

Edward Wiley