John Lyshitski

Dax Shepard

Nelson Biederman IV

Will Arnett

Barry

Chi McBride

Shanahan

David Koechner

Warden

Dylan Baker

Lynard

Michael Shannon

Jesus

Miguel Nino

Icepick

Jay Whittaker

Judge Eva Fwae Wun

Amy Hill

Judge Biederman

David Darlow

Duane

Bob Odenkirk

Pawn Broker

Joseph Marcus

Breen Guard

Jerry Minor

John (8 Years)

Nick Phalen

John (18 Years)

A.J. Balance

Old Bartender

Mary Seibel

Stripper

Susan Messing

Sgt. Barker

Jim Zulevic

Deputy Mayor

Bill McGough

Korean Pharmacist

Bert Matias

Mingha

Salome St. Clair

Chubby Prisoner

Scott Philyaw

Board Member #1

Jordan Teplitz

Wine Taster

Tim Heidecker

Board Member No. 2

Richard Bull

Wine Taster (uncredited)

Eric Wareheim

Bailiff

Mark Morettini

Black Juror

Llou Johnson

Old Juror

Nathan Davis

Cowboy Juror

Hans Holsen

Punk Juror

Dana Leone Hildreth

Prosecutor

Brad Berenson

Old Woman

Maureen Steindler

Derek

Larry Neumann Jr.

Reggie

Anthony Irons

Randy

Bradley Grant Smith

Latino Dude #1

Ramses Jimenez

Latino Dude #2

Eduardo N. Martinez

Cafeteria Worker

Ellis Foster

Visitation Guard

Laurent Crawford

Mexican Convict

Manny Sosa

Billy

Robert Gerdisch

Young Guard

Rich Wilkie

The Mule

Drew Hastings

Teacher

Sue Gillan

Tough Prisoner

Ripper Brown

Prisoner in Bathroom

Joe Nuñez

Parole Board Head

Peter Burns

Parole Board Member

Claudia Michelle Wallace

Guard #8

Craig J. Harris

Prisoner #3

Theron Touché Lykes

Coroner

Mick Napier

Wine Taster

Michael Hitchcock