Emma Reynolds

Alicia Witt

Morgan Shelby

Colin Ferguson

Cliff

Gary Lindemann

Andie

Laura Leighton

Rachel Jacobs

Jill Larson

Caroline Reynolds

Mary Elizabeth McDonough

Daniel

Jordan Dean

Ian

John Palladino

Rumi

Ariane Rinehart

Joe

Jose Ramon Rosario

Rodney

Jack Hallett

Anne Marie Reynolds

Blair Lewin

Mary Bernadette

Stephanie Berry

Grace

Debra Lord Cooke

Sophie

Fiona Morgan Quinn

Marco

Owen Dammacco

Maureen

Blair Busbee

Cookie Salesman

Vin Craig

Young Emma

Claire Keane

The Librarian

Jan Pessano

Holiday Shopper

Alex Barber

Morgan's Mother (uncredited)

Sherry H. Arell

Townsperson (uncredited)

Kami Cotler

House Party Guest

David Boston

Townsperson / party guest (uncredited)

Josiah Harvey

Townsperson (uncredited)

Michelle Patnode

Townsperson at Outdoor Concert (uncredited)

Bill Salvatore

Townsperson (uncredited)

Katie Vandrilla

Girlfriend

Arshenna Hines