Ziggy Berman
Sadie Sink
Cindy Berman
Emily Rudd
Alice
Ryan Simpkins
Sheila
Chiara Aurelia
Gary
Drew Scheid
Tommy Slater
McCabe Slye
Samantha Fraser
Olivia Welch
Young Nick Goode
Ted Sutherland
Young Will Goode
Brandon Spink
Becky
Marcelle LeBlanc
Annie
Eden Campbell
Kurt
Michael Provost
Joan
Jacqi Vene
Arnie
Sam Brooks
Deena Johnson
Kiana Madeira
Josh Johnson
Benjamin Flores Jr.
C. Berman / Adult Ziggy
Gillian Jacobs
Sheriff Nick Goode
Ashley Zukerman
Nurse Mary Lane
Jordana Spiro
Ruby Lane
Jordyn DiNatale
'The Milkman' Harry Rooker
Kevin Waterman
Billy Barker
Emily Brobst
'Shame Killer' Isaac Milton
Keil Oakley Zepernick
'The Pastor' Cyrus Miller
Michael Chandler
Sarah Fier
Elizabeth Scopel
Mayor Will Goode
Matthew Zuk
TV Anchor
Meghan Packer
Sunnyvale Cop
Jason Edwards
Young Officer Kapinski
Paul Teal
Jeremy
Dylan Gage Moore
Cool Sunnyvale Camper
Jayden Griffin
Shadyside Prisoner #1
Lana Spraley
Shadyside Prisoner #2
Ja'rell Anderson
EMT
Kenneth Trujillo
Mean Sunnyvale Jailer
Alex Huff