Deejay

Michael McHale

Nick Pearson

Tom Everett Scott

The Amazing Fabular

Tituss Burgess

Chaz

Lewie Bartone

Mason

Julian Feder

Sydney Bartlett

Rachel Boston

Jimmy

Johny Visotcky

Kelly

Rhea Seehorn

Joanna

Julie Ann Emery

Dad

Bo Foxworth

Richard

Andrew Bowen

Walter

Ray Abruzzo

Schyler Cross

Beth Riesgraf

Carla Intinoli

Maria de Lourdes Severny

Janice Bodicker

Arden Myrin

Daisy

Emily De Margheriti

Betty Bartlett

Joyce Bulifant

Reverend McGooley

Bryan Batt

Winifred 'Winny'/Freddy

Chris Levine

Phil Bartlett

Roger Perry

Christine Hurley

Marisa Tomei

Psychic #4

John Landis

Attendant

Jeris Poindexter

Psychic #2

Kimberly Blair

Mr.Sparkles

Roger

Frankie

Nathan Arenas

Old Annie

Patrice Barrie

Valet

Johnny Visotcky

CHP Officer Evans

Rico E. Anderson

Delivery Room Nurse #2

Mary Hollis Inboden

Tae Kwan Do Girl

Daisy Traina

Bridal shop employee

Stephane Nicoli

Delivery Room Doctor

David Loden

Delivery Room Nurse #1

Tiffany Yvonne Cox

Psychic #1

Todd Traina

Psychic #2

Rachel McHale

Wedding Guest

Kevyn Bashore

Psychic #5

Olivia Levine

Hero Kid

Akinyele Caldwell

Ex Girlfriend

Dita McCool

Security Guard

Ben Begley

Psychic

Sheila M. Lockhart

Groomsman

Jeremy Russell

Dancer

Michelle Arthur

Psychic

R.J. Asher

Golfer in Bathroom

Rob Flowers