Nick Crosby
Tom Arnold
Holly
Candace Cameron Bure
Peter
Christopher Wiehl
Ginny
Barbara Niven
Ben Richards
Matt Walton
Earl
Allan F. Nicholls
Brenda
Kaily Smith Westbrook
Brenda
Kaily Smith
Mr. Covell
Bruce Bouchard
Della
Heather Remick
Mr. Jennings
Richard Waterhouse
Willy
Taylor Ampatiellos
Young Holly
Lillian Pritchard
Young Peter
Ari Larson
Nick's Dog
Parma
Office worker (uncredited)
Gary Boyles
Ski Shop Elf (uncredited)
Adam Desautels
Elf waiter (uncredited)
Dave Kulvete
Willy's Mom (uncredited)
Emily George Lyons
Townsperson (uncredited)
R.W. Martin
Melissa Sagemiller
Brad Rowe
Marliss Amiea
Eddie Deezen
Christian Gehring
Laura Gordon
Dylan Hobbs
Martin Klebba
Caitlyn Leone