Catherine Claire

Amanda Seyfried

George Claire

James Norton

Justine Sokolov

Rhea Seehorn

Willis

Natalia Dyer

Mare Laughton

Karen Allen

Eddie Vayle

Alex Neustaedter

Floyd DeBeers

F. Murray Abraham

Travis Laughton

Michael O'Keefe

Bram

James Urbaniak

Cole Vayle

Jack Gore

Franny Claire

Ana Sophia Heger

Calvin Vayle

Michael Abbott Jr.

Peg

Charlotte Maier

Lynne

Kelcy Griffin

Audrey Claire

Kristin Griffith

Flirty Student

Olivia Boreham-Wing

Tom Claire

Cotter Smith

Husband #2

Ben Graney

Wife #1

Molly Jobe

Ella Vayle

Emily Dorsch

Husband #1

Joey Auzenne

Mrs. Smit

Elliot Frances Flynn

Librarian

Polly Lee

Pat

Dan Daily

Local Woman #1

Dawn McGee

Blind Woman

Maureen Young

Local Woman #2

Melinda Tanner

Poet

Alison Smith

Millicent

Marion McCorry

Andy

Joe Lanza

Martin

Peter Grosz

Mr. Pratt

Brian Corrigan

Mrs. Pratt

Jill Dalton

Bank Teller

James Hindman

Local Man

Peter Von Berg

Shelby Warren

Lewis Payton, Jr.

Shelby Warren

Lewis Payton

Reporter

Michelle Brown

Priest

Larry Petersen

Marine Worker

John Rue

Faculty Wife

Julie E. Davis

Library Patron (uncredited)

Norman Aaronson

Lucy Quayle (uncredited)

Abigail Nicholson

George's Student

Lexa Hayes