Nichole Schmidt

Thora Birch

Gabby Petito

Skyler Samuels

Brian Laundrie

Evan Hall

Brian Laundrie

Evan Arthur Hall

Joe Petito

Douglas Taurel

Rose

Monica Moore Smith

Agent Shaw

Matisha Baldwin

Jim Schmidt

Samuel Whitten

Officer #1

Lonzo Liggins

Officer #2

Brian Kinney

Reporter

Melanie Nelson

Miranda

Nikki SooHoo

John

Aaron Groben

Friend

Tyonne Chambers

Attorney

Jan Broberg

Produce Guy

Dymone Priestley

Network Reporter

Kimberly Houk

Tara Petito

Stacey Ann Turner

TJ

Bridger Johnson

FBI Agent

Pamela Beheshti

Violence Witness Restaurant Customer

Bryan Bernardi

Search and Rescue

Ron Beth

FBI Agent

Mario DeAngelis

Restaurant Patron

John Forker

FBI Agent

Dustin Freeman

Undercover Cop

Alireza Mirmontazeri

Angry Citizen

Joe Byron Symes

Roberta Laundrie

Cathy Tidwell

Officer

Matthew P. Watts

Sheriff

Chad Wright

Teton County Sheriff (uncredited)

Craig Gregersen

Reporter

Rowan Cooper