Lily Weil

Lucy Hale

Noah

Alex Wolff

Chloe Daniels

Kathryn Prescott

Amelia

Alexandra Shipp

Rosa

Nora Dunn

Jessica

Claudia Doumit

Rebecca Voller

Awkwafina

Officer Higgins

Colton Dunn

Thomas Daniels

Austin Butler

Sam

Jerry MacKinnon

Jill Weil

Michaela Watkins

James Weil

Austin Abrams

Lorraine Daniels

Brooke Smith

Jerry

Ian Gomez

Alicia

Esther Povitsky

Teacher

Jack McBrayer

Mr. Bemis

Satya Bhabha

Mike

Ronen Rubinstein

Olivia Weil

Sydney Lucas

Stony

Stony Blyden

Mike

Ronen Rubenstein

Carrie

Sasha Spielberg

Anna

Alana Baer

Biff

D.C. Pierson

Officer Clark

Matt Corboy

Sapphire

Artemis Pebdani

Rose

Gracie Watrous

Katie B

Sabina Friedman-Seitz

Goalie

Hayden Tweedie

Shot Girl

Chelsea O'Toole

Soccer Ref

Stephon Fuller

Crooner

Dana Williams

Soccer Player (uncredited)

Easton Alexeyev

High School Student (uncredited)

David S. Robinson Hicks

Goth Girl

Brooke Markham