Monica Sullivan

Denise Richards

Shane DeSoto

Patrick Muldoon

Ava Sullivan

Rhys Olivia Cote

Detective Lopez

Chelsea Vale

Dominick Sullivan

Andrew G. Bennett

Jimmy Dean

Sal Rendino

Young Dean

Joey Ambrosini

Crusher

Nick Principe

Houdini (voice)

Taylor Vale

Father Riley

Tommy Fury

Einstein (voice)

Blair Dinucci

Jackpot (voice)

Forest Quaglia

Mrs. Hope

Laura Poe

Mr. Crause

David Gere

Young Monica

Brittany Toczko

Troy

Jesse Figueiredo

Troy's Girlfriend

Stephanie Lyn

Waitress

Amari McDaniel

Groomsman

Stephen B. Reid

High School Teacher

Chris Baldyga

High School Student

Arienne Palumbo

High School Student

Joe Samonek

High School Student

Jackson Gower Taylor

High School Student

Kiara Cruz

High School Student

Esteban Cintron

Wedding Guest

Blaise Serra

Neighbor

Chad Verdi Jr.

Neighbor

Paul Luba

Neighbor

Audrey Fratelli

High School Student (uncredited)

Richard Sprandel

Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Eric Weinstock