Greg Gaines

Thomas Mann

Rachel Kushner

Olivia Cooke

Earl Jackson

RJ Cyler

Greg's Father

Nick Offerman

Greg's Mom

Connie Britton

Denise Kushner

Molly Shannon

Mr. McCarthy

Jon Bernthal

Derrick

Bobb'e J. Thompson

Naomi

Chelsea Zhang

Ill Phil

Masam Holden

Madison

Katherine Hughes

Scott Mayhew

Matt Bennett

Young Greg

George Gavin Dietz*

Anna

Natalie Marchelletta

Young Greg

Gavin Dietz

Young Earl

Edward DeBruce III

Theater Dork

Marco Zappala

Rachel's Friend

Kaza Marie Ayersman

Principal

Etta Cox

Limo Driver

Karriem Sami

Hugh Jackman (voice)

Hugh Jackman

Rabbi

Cheryl Klein

Elderly Mourner

Joan Augustin

Rabbi

Cheryl Kline

Testimonial Student #1

Mark Granatire

Testimonial Student #2

Kayana White

Testimonial Student #3

Linda Kanyarusoke

Testimonial Student #4

Drew Palajsa

Testimonial Student #5

Elly Silberstein

Children's Hospital Nurse

Nicole Tubbs

Shiva Attendee (uncredited)

Joe Fishel

Theater Student (uncredited)

Jeremy Long

High School Student (uncredited)

Zander Lyons

Friend (uncredited)

Jake Scheib

School Teacher (uncredited)

Jackson Nunn

Prep Student

Andrew James Bleidner