Rio Cutler

Jake Schur

Sheriff Pat Garrett

Ethan Hawke

Billy "The Kid" Bonney

Dane DeHaan

Sara Cutler

Leila George

Grant Cutler

Chris Pratt

Bob Olinger

Adam Baldwin

Billy Wilson

Charlie Chappell

Tom Pickett

Clint Obenchain

Charlie Bowdre

Chris Bylsma

Bill Cutler

Tait Fletcher

Dave Rudabaugh

Chad Dashnaw

Jim East

Benjamin Dickey

Oran Moler

Hawk D'Onofrio

Paulita Maxwell

Samantha Zajarias

Sheriff Romero

Vincent D'Onofrio

Manuela

Diana Navarrete

First Reporter

David Devereaux

Cricket (Whore)

Rachel Singer

Mirabel

Jenny Gabrielle

Tall Man

Howard Ferguson Jr.

Butcher

Santo Militello

Paul Jankowski

Keith Jardine

Second Guard

Dillon D. Jordan

James Bell

Joseph Santos

Bank Clerk

Leslie Fleming-Mitchell

Older Doctor

Joe Berryman

Gauss

Douglas Bennett

Mexican Worker

Efrain Villa

John Poe

Stafford Douglas

Singing Painted Lady

Merritt C. Glover

Bartender

Jacob Browne

Young Whore

MorningStar Angeline

Father

David Christian Welborn

Stagecoach Daughter

Georgia Kirshenbaum

Stagecoach Son

Cameron Thurlow

Young Mob Leader

Carlos Amorin

T. Wingate

Thomas Wingate

Mother

Danielle Haynes

Townsperson

Cynthia Casaus

Mother Maxwell (uncredited)

Rose Cordova

Hispanic School Teacher (uncredited)

Rachel de la Torre

Wash lady (uncredited)

Yvette Fazio-Delaney

Brothel Woman #2 (uncredited)

Shannon Henderson Herrera

Townsman (uncredited)

Christian Dalton

Santa Fe Policeman (uncredited)

David Hight

Townsperson (uncredited)

Sarah Murrey

Townsperson (uncredited)

J. Nathan Simmons

Rip Lowe

Brothel Woman

Darlene Kellum

Santa Fe Policeman

Bob Knowlton

Townsperson

Adrian Luna

The Cook

Randy Outzen

Store Clerk

Michael Neal Powell

Townswoman

Kimberly Rayman

Townsman

Michael E. Stogner

Santa Fe Police Officer

Rick Tadra

Manuela

Diana Navarrette