Tyler

Robert Pattinson

Ally Craig

Emilie de Ravin

Charles Hawkins

Pierce Brosnan

Neil Craig

Chris Cooper

Diane Hirsch

Lena Olin

Toothbrush Girl

Athena Currey

Caroline Hawkins

Ruby Jerins

Aidan Hall

Tate Ellington

Les Hirsch

Gregory Jbara

Janine

Kate Burton

Alyssa Craig's Mom (uncredited)

Martha Plimpton

Megan

Meghan Markle

Leo

Chris McKinney

Alyssa Craig (11 yrs)

Caitlyn Paige Rund

Michael Hawkins

Christopher Clawson

Miami Blonde

Emily Wickersham

Megan

Meghan

Police Chief

Kevin P. McCarthy

Miami Brunette

Kelli Barrett

Mugger

Moisés Acevedo

Mugger

Noel Rodriguez

Taunting Classmate

Morgan Turner

Taunting Classmate

Peyton List

Diner Waitress

Angela Pietropinto

Uptight Mommy

Lee Brock

Oak Room Waiter

Michael Hobbs

Musician

Jon Trotsky

Musician

Drew Leary

NYU Professor

David Deblinger

Queens Guy

Bob Colletti

Musician

Jon Trosky

Queens Guy

Scott Burik

Queens Guy

William Cote Kruschwitz

Queens Guy

Doug Crosby

Escorting Officer

Scott Nicholson

Receptionist

Tricia Paoluccio

Queens Guy

William Cote

Queens Guy

Douglas Crosby

Aidan's Professor

Olga Merediz

Indian Restaurant Waiter

Ebrahim Abe Jaffer

Carny Game Attendant

David Anzuelo

Indian Restaurant Waiter

Ebrahim Jaffer

Cab Driver

Sandor Tecsy

Rookie Cop

Justin Grace

Business Associate

David Wilson Barnes

Birthday Girl's Mom

Jane Harnick

Birthday Girl

Emily Godshall

Caroline's Teacher

Andrea Navedo

Bailiff

William H. Burns

Bailiff

Bill Burns

Ally's Girlfriend (uncredited)

Amy Rosoff

Young Interviewee (uncredited)

Ben Hauck

Thug in Holding Cell (uncredited)

Martin Pfefferkorn