Barrett Malcolm

Molly

Felicia Day

Derrick

Malcolm Barrett

Susan

Lyndie Greenwood

David

Wil Wheaton

Day Felicia

Matt

Jonah Ray Rodrigues

Ellie

Rachel Bloom

Bennie Taylor

Gavin Stenhouse

Matt

Jonah Ray

Amir

Amir Talai

Jax

Motoki Maxted

Becky

Laurel Toupal

Andy

Ben Weinswig

Lauren

Willow Beuoy

Animal Pooka

Alexander Ward

Demon Pooka

Gene Freeman

Bar Patron

Ken Dickason Sr.

Bartender

Lucas Hyde

Pooka Livestreamer

Jessie Epstein

Andy's Colleague

Harrison Meloeny

Reporter

Laurie Perez