Gerry Fenn

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Father Hagan

William Sadler

Alice

Cricket Brown

Father Prescott

Bill Thorpe

Photographer/Reporter

Janelle Feigley

Bishop Gyles

Cary Elwes

Nun

Julia Bechler

Faithful #3

Kiara Pichardo

Dr. Natalie Gates

Katie Aselton

Internet Woman

Andrea Athanassiou

Monsignor Delgarde

Diogo Morgado

Grace Father

Cassidy Neal

Mary Elnor

Marina Mazepa

Geary

Bates Wilder

Toby Walsh

Danny Corbo

Librarian

Celeste Oliva

Faithful #4

Kevin Fennessy

Monica Slade

Christine Adams

Dan Walsh

Dustin Tucker

Sophia Walsh

Gisela Chípe

Toby Walsh

Sonny Corbo

Max

Michael Strauss

Faithful Teen Girl

Madison LaPlante

Waitress

Doria Bramante

Atheist Man

Stephen O'Neil Martin

Correspondent

Tim Estiloz

Correspondent

Ted Wayman

Internet Woman

Hannah Jane Doyon

Nervous Man Leaving Town

Charlie Thurston

Shopkeeper

Chris Byers

Faithful #1

Mere Davis

Faithful #2

Dave Heard

Blacksmith

Mike Wendt

Journalist

Lisa Gresci

Mary Elnor (voice)

Lorna Larkin

City Official (uncredited)

Rob Lévesque

Talk Show Host (uncredited)

J.J. Wright

Camera Crew (uncredited)

Adrian M. Mompoint

Church Goer (uncredited)

Jonathan Neves

Church Member (uncredited)

Nicholas Trotto