Father Peter

Guy Pearce

Father Louis

Keith David

Father Daniel

Vadhir Derbez

Robin Bartlett

Stephen Lang

Helen

Robin Bartlett

Charlie Giroux

Brady Jenness

Mrs. Miller

Hannah Alline

Young Peter

Chris Galust

Mr. Miller

Heath Freeman

Charlie's Father

Major Dodge

George

Acoryé White

Coroner

Ben Hicks

Juvenile Detention Kid (uncredited)

Riley Fitzgerald

Forensic Psychologist

James Healy Jr.

Nicholas Miller

Tristan Riggs

Charlie's Mother

Stephanie Rhodes

Carson

Bjorgvin Arnarson

Nellie

Evangeline Griffin

Police Officer #2 (uncredited)

Craig Cole

Aaron

Johari Turner

Homeless Guy

Marque Hernandez

Jazzy

Grace E Gonzalez

Administrator

Mykle McCoslin

Sherman

Seth Gutierrez

Guard #2

David Opegbemi

Archbishop's Secretary

Gail Cronauer

Detention Center Kid (uncredited)

Braden Balazik

Older employee

Ruben Gary Martinez

Priest

Gary Lee Reed

Father Dunleavy

Garrett Schweighauser

Young Daniel

Silas De La Rosa

Young Daniel's Friend #1

Ethan Pogue

Young Daniel's Friend #2

Joe Colaleo

Young Daniel's Friend #3

Riley Irvin

Guard #1

Cecilia Okoye

News Reporter

Jancey Sheats