Elliot Sherman

Michael Showalter

Caroline Swann

Elizabeth Banks

Cecil Mills

Michelle Williams

Bradley Lake

Justin Theroux

Wendall Wimms

Zak Orth

Ed

Michael Ian Black

Stella

Catherine Lloyd Burns

Benson Hedges

Peter Dinklage

Bar Baxter No. 2

Joe Lo Truglio

Dan Abbott

Paul Rudd

Sonya Simmons

Katharine Powell

Kimberly

Abby Wathen

Alan Swann

John DeVries

Louis Lewis

David Wain

Lilly

Melisa McGregor

Serena

Sarah Drew

Wedding Guest

Madeleine Dauzart

Judy Swann

Donna Mitchell

Elliot's Friend

Jack McBrayer

Jack Mechanic

Ken Marino

Kate

Haviland Morris

Leonard Sherman

Jim DeMarse

Sheila Sherman

Leslie Lyles

Bar Baxter No. 1

A.D. Miles

Bar Baxter No. 3

Seth Herzog

Bar Baxter No. 4

Jonathan Marc Sherman

Young Elliot

Peter Stadlen

Max

Gabriel Millman

Tanner Bates

Chris Spain

Delores

Marylouise Burke

Pastor Pritchard

Audrie Neenan

Emcee

Bobby Tisdale

Interpretive Dancer

Michael Portnoy

Muffy

Maya Goldsmith

Peg

Jenny Maguire

Bridesmaid

Andrea Rosen

Director

Michael Showalter