Scott Carlin

Pete Davidson

Margie Carlin

Marisa Tomei

Kelsey

Bel Powley

Ray Bishop

Bill Burr

Oscar

Ricky Velez

Richie

Lou Wilson

Igor

Moises Arias

Claire Carlin

Maude Apatow

Papa

Steve Buscemi

Tara

Carly Aquilino

Gina

Pamela Adlon

Jimmy Bags' Brother

Robert Vidal, III

Shot or Stabbed Victim

Action Bronson

Kids Who Vomits

Angus Costello

Joe

Kevin Corrigan

Joanne

Pauline Chalamet

Harold

Luke David Blumm

Joy

Lynne Koplitz

Todd

Joseph Paul Kennedy

Joanne's Mother

Nina Hellman

Joanne's Father

Jack Hamblin

Grandpa

Stephen Davidson

Security Guard

Keith Robinson

Waitress at Denino's

Liza Treyger

Woman Eating in Restaurant

Meredith Handerhan

Husband Ordering in Restaurant

Rich Vos

Security Guard

Keith Robinson

Wife Ordering in Restaurant

Bonnie McFarlane

Pepe

Jay Rodriguez

Firefighter Savage

Jimmy Tatro

Zoots

Derek Gaines

Firefighter Jaylen Patterson

Giselle King

Captain Palazzo

John Sorrentino

Kelly

Alexis Rae Forlenza

Firefighter Lockwood

Domenick Lombardozzi

Firefighter Morales

Rafael Poueriet

Kindergarten Teacher

Nana Mensah

Tattoo Shop Owner (as Colson Baker)

Machine Gun Kelly

Tattoo Customer

Kill

Kelsey's Tinder Date

Anthony Lee Medina

'What's Your Major?' Girl at College Bar

Nyla Durdin

Aspiring Actress at College Bar

Katherine Ray Zimmerman

1% Girl in Dorm Room

Lilly Brown

Male Pharmacy Owner

Robert Smigel

Female Pharmacy Owner

Jessica Kirson

Second Cop at Pharmacy

David Lomax

Carla

Casey Davidson

Dougie

Antony Marino

Man Yelling in Backyard

Nils Johnson

Firefighter Rivera

Mario Polit

First Cop at Pharmacy

Laurence Blum

Firefighter Thompson

Mike Vecchione

Second Cop at Pharmacy

David S. Lomax

Firefighter Gardner

Hank Strong

Admissions Nurse in ER

Marilyn Torres

Patient in Pain in ER

Teodorina Bello

Doctor in ER

Michelle Sohn

Bar Patron

Vincent Paolicelli

Frat Guy (uncredited)

Matthew Brandt

Staten Island Yankees Fan (uncredited)

Kadrolsha Ona Carole

School Kid (uncredited)

Raina Cheng

Staten island Yankee (uncredited)

Leonys Delossantos

Baseball Fan

Gina Jun

Bar Patron / Baseball Fan (uncredited)

Anthony Ferrara

Patient (uncredited)

Ken Holmes

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Adam Keane

Staten Island Yankees Fan (uncredited)

Mark Lehneman

Restaurant Patron (uncredited)

Bob Leszczak

School Kid (uncredited)

Nico Chang Lynch

Director

Judd Apatow