Scott Carlin
Pete Davidson
Margie Carlin
Marisa Tomei
Kelsey
Bel Powley
Ray Bishop
Bill Burr
Oscar
Ricky Velez
Richie
Lou Wilson
Igor
Moises Arias
Claire Carlin
Maude Apatow
Papa
Steve Buscemi
Tara
Carly Aquilino
Gina
Pamela Adlon
Jimmy Bags' Brother
Robert Vidal, III
Shot or Stabbed Victim
Action Bronson
Kids Who Vomits
Angus Costello
Joe
Kevin Corrigan
Joanne
Pauline Chalamet
Harold
Luke David Blumm
Joy
Lynne Koplitz
Todd
Joseph Paul Kennedy
Joanne's Mother
Nina Hellman
Joanne's Father
Jack Hamblin
Grandpa
Stephen Davidson
Security Guard
Keith Robinson
Waitress at Denino's
Liza Treyger
Woman Eating in Restaurant
Meredith Handerhan
Husband Ordering in Restaurant
Rich Vos
Security Guard
Keith Robinson
Wife Ordering in Restaurant
Bonnie McFarlane
Pepe
Jay Rodriguez
Firefighter Savage
Jimmy Tatro
Zoots
Derek Gaines
Firefighter Jaylen Patterson
Giselle King
Captain Palazzo
John Sorrentino
Kelly
Alexis Rae Forlenza
Firefighter Lockwood
Domenick Lombardozzi
Firefighter Morales
Rafael Poueriet
Kindergarten Teacher
Nana Mensah
Tattoo Shop Owner (as Colson Baker)
Machine Gun Kelly
Tattoo Customer
Kill
Kelsey's Tinder Date
Anthony Lee Medina
'What's Your Major?' Girl at College Bar
Nyla Durdin
Aspiring Actress at College Bar
Katherine Ray Zimmerman
1% Girl in Dorm Room
Lilly Brown
Male Pharmacy Owner
Robert Smigel
Female Pharmacy Owner
Jessica Kirson
Second Cop at Pharmacy
David Lomax
Carla
Casey Davidson
Dougie
Antony Marino
Man Yelling in Backyard
Nils Johnson
Firefighter Rivera
Mario Polit
First Cop at Pharmacy
Laurence Blum
Firefighter Thompson
Mike Vecchione
Second Cop at Pharmacy
David S. Lomax
Firefighter Gardner
Hank Strong
Admissions Nurse in ER
Marilyn Torres
Patient in Pain in ER
Teodorina Bello
Doctor in ER
Michelle Sohn
Bar Patron
Vincent Paolicelli
Frat Guy (uncredited)
Matthew Brandt
Staten Island Yankees Fan (uncredited)
Kadrolsha Ona Carole
School Kid (uncredited)
Raina Cheng
Staten island Yankee (uncredited)
Leonys Delossantos
Baseball Fan
Gina Jun
Bar Patron / Baseball Fan (uncredited)
Anthony Ferrara
Patient (uncredited)
Ken Holmes
Bar Patron (uncredited)
Adam Keane
Staten Island Yankees Fan (uncredited)
Mark Lehneman
Restaurant Patron (uncredited)
Bob Leszczak
School Kid (uncredited)
Nico Chang Lynch