Alex

Ema Horvath

Carey

John Ales

Pizza Guy

Xzavier Beacham

Sarah

Yeardley Smith

Karl

Devon Sawa

Therapist

Ayanna Berkshire

Judith

Alyssa Milano

Nancy

Kiah Butts

Young Alex

Juniper Catalino

Rohan

Siddharth Dhananjay

Party Guest

A. Brian Daniels

Reggie

Peter Parros

Arthur

Reid Miller

Beau

Duffy Epstein

Carlo Hernandez

Geneviève J. Galliani

Church Couple (Man)

Carlo Hernandez

Eliza

Keziah Wall

Rose

Delyn Wall

Gayle

Jenna Louie Lohouse

Substitute Teacher

Jeanine Jackson

Student

Naomi Klockars

Church Member

Debbie Marr

Mean Girl

Lauren Wafer

Headmistress

Elizabeth Huffman

Lyft Driver

Rob Nelson

Minister

Laura Duyn

Student

Elizabeth O'Brien

Delivery Guy

Wolfie Beacham

Grandmother

Suzanne Owens-Duval