Ed Gein

Charlie Hunnam

Aileen Wuornos

Charlize Theron

Selby Wall

Christina Ricci

Adeline Watkins

Suzanna Son

Alfred Hitchcock

Tom Hollander

Thomas

Bruce Dern

Augusta Gein

Laurie Metcalf

Horton/Last "John"

Scott Wilson

Vincent Corey

Lee Tergesen

Gene/Stuttering "John"

Pruitt Taylor Vince

Ilse Koch

Vicky Krieps

Donna Tentler

Annie Corley

Anthony Perkins

Joey Pollari

Sheriff Schley

Tyler Jacob Moore

Evan / Undercover "John"

Marco St. John

Lesley Manville

Will / Daddy "John"

Marc Macaulay

Cop

Rus Blackwell

Alma Reville

Olivia Williams

Chuck

Tim Ware

Lawyer

Stephan Jones

Charles

Brett Rice

Teenage Aileen

Kaitlin Riley

7-Year-Old Aileen

Cree Ivey

Justy

Catherine Mangan

Bar Lap Girl

Magdelena Manville

Bar Lap Girl

Magdalena Manville

Bartender

T. Robert Pigott

Restaurant Manager

Glenn R. Wilder

Employment Agent

Romonda Shaver

Undercover Cop

Kane Hodder

Wife at Accident

Elaine Stebbins

Undercover Cop

Christian Stokes

Bar Girl

Lyllian Barcaski

Cubby

Bubba Baker

Bar Girl

Nonalee Davis

Trevor

Chad Vaccarino

Himself

Al

Skate Rink Attendant

Jesse Stern

Himself

Cannonball

Newscaster

Jim R. Coleman

Judge

Gene R. Stephenson

Cute Teenage Attendant

Chandra Leigh

Police Chief

Billy Boylan

Attendant

Lori McDonald

Attendant

Adam Brown

State Prison Guard (uncredited)

Ed Donovan