Sheryl Bradshaw

Anna Kendrick

Ed

Tony Hale

Rodney

Daniel Zovatto

Laura

Nicolette Robinson

Sarah

Kelley Jakle

Ken

Max Lloyd-Jones

Bachelor #2

Jedidiah Goodacre

Amy

Autumn Best

Terry

Pete Holmes

Charlie

Kathryn Gallagher

Casting Director

Matty Finochio

Lisa

Jessie Fraser

Bachelor #1

Matt Visser

Custodian (George Elliot)

Rob Morton

Mario

Dylan Schmid

Gretchen

Karen Holness

Marilyn

Denalda Williams

Casting Director

Geoff Gustafson

Bob

Andy Thompson

Diane

Nancy Kerr

Joe

James Yi

Helen

Jessica Chaffin

Mark

Matthew Kevin Anderson

Melanie

Taylor Hastings

Rodney's Boss

David Beairsto

Marty

Darcy Laurie

Head Mover

Marc Gaudet

Bartender

Bonnie Hay

Dating Game Director

Michael Adamthwaite

Dating Game 1st Assistant Director

Jacob Woike

Dating Game Announcer

Jason Simpson

Bachelorette (Playback)

Hannah Henney

Bachelor (Playback)

Tighe Gill

Booth Security Guard (Harold)

Michael Jonsson

Typist

Vonnie Bennetto

Laundromat Owner

Thomas Strumpski

Detective

John Herkenrath

Detective

Jeremy Radin

Alison

Cody Heller