Ida Graber
Kimberly Williams-Paisley
Amy Roberts
Tammy Blanchard
Gideon Graber
Matt Letscher
Jill Green
Fay Masterson
Levi Brennaman
Madison Mason
Henry Taskey
Gary Graham
Rebecca Knepp
Darcy Rose Byrnes
Katie Graber
Karley Scott Collins
Danny
Eugene Byrd
Rachel Knepp
Amy Sloan
Leonard
Bruce Nozick
Charlie Roberts
John Churchill
Mary Beth Graber
Madison Davenport
State Trooper
Eric Nenninger
Judith
Willow Geer
Minister
Christopher Curry
Shelly
Kate Fuglei
Sheriff
Jim Metzler
Reporter
Bob Rumnock
Teacher Ruth
Emilee Wallace
Melinda
Jessica Dickey
Sarah Knepp
Chloe Madison
Hannah
Taylor Ann Thompson
Jacob
Trevor Thompson
Andy Roberts
David Mazouz
Rachel's Husband
Dale Wade Davis
Melinda's Husband
Joel Schmidt
Amish Elder
David Curtis
Knepp Boy #1
Sammy Jack
Knepp Boy #2
Gabriel Welch
Ryan Roberts
Elijah Tadros
Schoolboy (uncredited)
Caleb Babcock
Lilly (uncredited)
Daphne Blunt
State Trooper (uncredited)
Rick L. Dean
News Cameraman (uncredited)
Paul Edney
Lydia (uncredited)
Isabella Interian
Knepp Teenager (uncredited)
Marcus Shultz
Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)
Johnny Wilson