Brooks Rattigan

Noah Centineo

Celia Lieberman

Laura Marano

Murph

Odiseas Georgiadis

Shelby Pace

Camila Mendes

Charlie Rattigan

Matt Walsh

Jerry Lieberman

Joe Chrest

Warren

Evan Castelloe

Delbert Newhouse

Wayne Pere

Lillian Lieberman

Carrie Lazar

Tuna Melt on Seven Grain

Alexander Biglane

Franklin Volley

Blaine Kern III

Reese

Zak Steiner

Cartelli

Ty Parker

Bespectacled Woman

Sue-Lyn Ansari

Miss Milligan

Rhonda Johnson Dents

Marjorie Strack

Maureen Brennan

Toby

Jared Bankens

Leah

Autumn Walker

Larry

Ivan Hoey Jr.

Cute Girl

Trina LaFargue

Girl

Emily Chatelain

Female Jock

Krystal Tomlin

Secretary

Sharon Elizabeth Smith

Gino's Patron

Rusty Bourg

Don the Clerk

Phi Vu

Valet Guy

Hawn Tran

Greenwich Prep Student

Natalie Sibille

Sub Shop Patron (uncredited)

Mike Young