John Bishop

Michael Lombardi

Jed Sawyer

Marc Menchaca

Sarah Bishop

Katie Kelly

Ram Kady

Joseph Gatt

Rebecca Bishop

Abbey Hafer

Quinn Brady

Jacoby Shaddix

Otto

Robert Knepper

Vic

Ivan Moody

Captain Briggs

Robert John Burke

Max

Spencer Charnas

Debbie

Shannan Wilson

Strip Club DJ

Tommy Lee

Vic Kady

Ivan L. Moody

Fang

Zoltan Bathory

Decker

Chris Kael

Erica

Amanda Lyberg

Mutant

Craig Mabbitt

Church Band Member

Matt Brandyberry

Joey

Doc Coyle

Cynthia

Gigi Gustin

Church Band Member

Danny Case

Church Band Member

Lance Dowdle

April

Corrie Graham

Aunt Jody

Cree Kelly

Sofie

Rachel Hilbert

Bishop

Michael J. Lombardi

Christmas Tree Lot Jerk

Brian O'Halloran

Jimmy

Cory Marks

Officer Kelly

Dominic Costa

Police Officer

Brian Gallagher

Stoner Gas Station Attendant #1

Dan Murphy

Stoner Gas Station Attendant #2

Miles Franco

Bishop's Wife

Meghan Noone

Christmas Farm Cashier

Angelina Aucello

Subhuman

Kristoffe Brodeur

AA Participant

Jeff Fuell

Cruz

Jason Hook

Dancer

Natalie Kline

Subhuman

Ari Loeb

Sharon

Gemma McIlhenny

Obnoxious Dad

Skyler Stone