Nick

Michael Cera

Norah

Kat Dennings

Tris

Alexis Dziena

Thom

Aaron Yoo

Caroline

Ari Graynor

Dev

Rafi Gavron

Tal

Jay Baruchel

Beefy Guy (Lethario)

Jonathan B. Wright

Gary

Zachary Booth

Bishop Allen band member

Christian Rudder

Bishop Allen

Justin Rice

Randy (Are You Randy)

Jeremy Haines

Bishop Allen band member

Giorgio Angelini

Sammy (Are You Randy)

Sammy Marc Rubin

Drunk Guy in Yugo

Seth Meyers

Drunk Girl in Yugo

Lorene Scafaria

Bishop Allen

Darbie Nowatka

Homeless Man

Andy Samberg

Bishop Allen

Cully Symington

Switzerland

Billy Griffith

Jesus

Eddie Kaye Thomas

Korean Guy

Glenn Kubota

Ticket Salesman

Frankie Faison

Ukrainian Waitress

Marika Daciuk

Hype Man

John Cho

Drunk Kid

Marcel Simoneau

Man at Port Authority

Kevin Corrigan

Homeless Caroline

Ruth Maleczech

Janitor

Marilyn McDonald

Nellie Olesons

John Cantwell

Nellie Olesons

Nora Burns

Nellie Olesons

Eric Bernat

Are You Randy Fan

Toney Chem

Customer in Deli

Devendra Banhart

Hipster (uncredited)

Steve Antonucci

Groupie (uncredited)

Joey Auzenne

Running Partying Man on Street (uncredited)

Joseph Basile

Hipster (uncredited)

Stephanie Ellis

Hipster Dancer (uncredited)

Natalia Fedner

Hipster (uncredited)

Cassidy Gard

Tal's Bandmate (uncredited)

Joe Giorgio

Drag Queen (uncredited)

Mimi Imfurst

Cute Bandboy (uncredited)

Jonesy

Veselka Diner Patron (uncredited)

David Levithan

Bartender (uncredited)

Kelli Mandruk

Hipster (uncredited)

Lance R. Marshall

Brooklyn Pool Bouncer (uncredited)

Frank Pelligra

Lesbian on Street (uncredited)

Nicole Pursell

Hipster (uncredited)

Sam Rocco

(voice) (uncredited)

Jill Sayre

Extra (uncredited)

Kiki Valentine

Norah's Father (uncredited)

Richard Waddingham

Brooklyn Hipster (uncredited)

Rachel Kiri Walker

Homeless at PABT (uncredited)

Bill Walters