Emily Stoll
Kyra Sedgwick
Paul (age 6)
Dominic Scott Kay
Marty Stoll
Kevin Bacon
Mark
Matt Dillon
Jeanette Rawley
Blair Brown
Mr. Pomeroy
Oliver Platt
Mrs. Harker
Sandra Bullock
Paul's Father
Campbell Scott
Sybil Stoll
Marisa Tomei
Emily (age 10)
Sosie Bacon
Lenny
Travis Bacon
Allen Rawley
John Lafayette
Miss Silken
Melissa Errico
Anita Biddle
Jessica Stone
Ruth
Carolyn McCormick
Allison
Naelee Rae
Allison (16 years old)
Valyn Hall
Principal
Nancy Giles
UPS Delivery Man
John Elsen
Paul (16 years old)
Spencer Treat Clark
Library Donor
Nick Gregory
Memphis Parking Lot Donor
John Legend
School Kid #1 (uncredited)
Steven Hinkle
Coke Bottle Glasses Donor
Andrew Polk
Emily's 3rd Grade Teacher
Rob Sedgwick
Crossing Guard
Susan Mieras
Paul's Pal Jeff
Zack Savage