Ben Dwellman

Jason Ritter

Alan Manilow

Jake Sandvig

Kelsey Patterson

Chandler Canterbury

Melanie 'Mel' Manilow

Rebecca Hall

Lynette

Carrie Preston

Marty

Todd Louiso

Wyatt

Gabriel Macht

Older Jewish Lady

Sally Kirkland

The Mark

Elmarie Wendel

Amanda (uncredited)

Amanda Seyfried

Cop

Josh Cooke

Erik

Erik Eidem

Kelsey Patterson (Age 18)

Johnny Simmons

Vince

Micah Hauptman

Scott Owen

Jordan-Claire Green

Jorge

Ricardo Chacon

Temp Agency Interviewer 1

Greg Clark

Temp Agency Interviewer 2

Devika Parikh

Temp Agency Interviewer 3

Philip Pavel

Hobo

Barbara Rossmiesl

Young Alan

Cameron Palatas

Young Ben

Glenn McCuen

Eliot

Patrick Hebel

Food Bank Volunteer

Kenyetta Lethridge

Neighbor

Dale Waddington Horowitz