Ben Dwellman
Jason Ritter
Alan Manilow
Jake Sandvig
Kelsey Patterson
Chandler Canterbury
Melanie 'Mel' Manilow
Rebecca Hall
Lynette
Carrie Preston
Marty
Todd Louiso
Wyatt
Gabriel Macht
Older Jewish Lady
Sally Kirkland
The Mark
Elmarie Wendel
Amanda (uncredited)
Amanda Seyfried
Cop
Josh Cooke
Erik
Erik Eidem
Kelsey Patterson (Age 18)
Johnny Simmons
Vince
Micah Hauptman
Scott Owen
Jordan-Claire Green
Jorge
Ricardo Chacon
Temp Agency Interviewer 1
Greg Clark
Temp Agency Interviewer 2
Devika Parikh
Temp Agency Interviewer 3
Philip Pavel
Hobo
Barbara Rossmiesl
Young Alan
Cameron Palatas
Young Ben
Glenn McCuen
Eliot
Patrick Hebel
Older Jewish Lady
Sally Kirkland*
Food Bank Volunteer
Kenyetta Lethridge
Neighbor
Dale Waddington Horowitz